When one thinks about ‘Blog for Jordan Day’ one thinks of the beautiful and magnificent things we love about Jordan to share with all those both from Jordan, to share an experience that they might not have had, OR people from outside of Jordan to draw them an image of all that is breathtaking about Jordan so that they might visit some day. See i’m not a person who loves pointing out the bad just for the sake of it, but i believe it would never really be fixed unless everyone pointed out that this or that is a problem.
Anyway so i decided to make my ‘Blog for JO day’ post on cyber censorship since today is the ‘World Day Against Cyber Censorship’. This issue is everywhere, from several articles a day in the same newspaper to everyone who basically lives online and would suffocate if his right to speak out was to be taken away.
Articles everywhere are talking about how not any person behind a screen can be called a writer, they’re talking about how they need sites to censor everything so no individuals can be trashed or talked badly about, there are all kinds of opinions out there and a lot of them just seem to want to take jordan backwards a few hundred steps and not just two. I can’t seem to get my mind off the thought of how afraid they must be to want to censor every word, it’s not about people making up stuff about other people and all those news sites making stories up, that is a problem with the readers, working on teaching them the difference between a site and another is in my opinion much more needed than censoring and coming after anyone who breathes in the wrong direction online.
Fear, i would say is the main reason behind such a decision, not fear of what might be made up but fear of all the hidden truths that might come up when a person can freely say whatever they want online or offline for that matter. And if we were ever to win this war and be able to voice out our thoughts from behind a screen then i don’t think there would be anything to make us look behind our backs and think twice and three times in real life. Once a person backs down from typing something or even types it but goes back to delete it or change this word or that our country will remain one lead by a few chosen who know not what the citizens want and need. This fear must be erased by the idea that most of our opinions can be used to fix all that is wrong and that would open up so many opportunities for Jordan to move up the ladder.
It should be my right, whether from behind closed doors or out in the public to be able to throw my opinions right and left for those who ask or care, it should be my right to form opinions based on my own thoughts or anyone else’s information on everything and anything on earth, from services to leaders to policies, religion and spirituality all the way down to the way the road is paved outside of my door. Why do you not want people to engage in discussion that will enrich us and make us use our brains for once? Why is everything sacred and haram and ’7aki bin7akash 2odam il 3alam’ ? Why do all schools and universities worldwide have a debate team to learn to have a meaningful discussion on things from a young age but the only discussing we’re aloud to have regarding rules and regulations is posting a blog post that’ll only be read by people who agree in the first place? I was born without your help and no rules were there, i will die the same way too, i don’t think rules should suddenly pop up continuously in between, and that is not only regarding online censorship but life in general.
Maybe the people behind this idea should think about a simple example: Teenagers are taught to act in a certain way and always told not to do this or that. Reaction? Yes mom and dad i will obey you, OK now out of the window, into dad’s car (no license) and let’s drive to that party. Another example would be: Boy/girl have lived their entire life around people of their own gender and spent 12 years of school also with same gender, once they’re off to university with other gender there’s no telling how they act, they rebel against what they’ve known their entire lives. So to wrap it up, be careful of such a decision because the people can only be told what to do for so long and then in one moment the rebellious will show up and we will be no different than other countries who were sick of things and decided to stand up.*
*Yes this means what you think it means, a revolution of some kind.







18 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 12, 2010 at 7:05 pm
On #B4JO & Web Censorship « 5hadz
[...] them up. Or when I can’t argue about who’s governing my own country. As fellow blogger Dee said, this is bound to create a [...]
March 12, 2010 at 9:16 pm
kinziblogs
Good words, Dee. I enjoy reading your perspectives.
March 12, 2010 at 10:22 pm
Dee
thank youuu
you know i love reading your blog too
March 12, 2010 at 9:32 pm
Haitham
shit, are we supposed to blog about things we love about Jordan?! Busted!
March 12, 2010 at 10:23 pm
Dee
ya3ni howeh yofadal :p ma 2asaret tab3an inta :p
March 12, 2010 at 10:10 pm
Shadz
Love your mention of web censorship, you took all the ideas out of my head. Would have enjoyed more about Jordan and a little less about just censorship, because people are getting the wrong idea behind #B4JO. Also, if you really think about it, we never really had the freedom of speech everyone is complaining we don’t have anymore. We were born into a country where it’s “الله، الوطن، الملك” and we’ve always abided by that, law or no law.
March 12, 2010 at 10:24 pm
Dee
exactly, but it was a bit more a no law thing before, and you can only wander what changes will happen now.. we’ll just have to wait and see..
March 12, 2010 at 10:42 pm
Qwaider قويدر
I’m sorry Dee, but you make it sound like we’ve been living in this oasis of liberties and freedoms and now all of a sudden someone is going to pull the rug from under our feet!
Please, don’t get me wrong, I’m not trying to criticize you or your ideas. I do hope that we achieve more liberties and greater civility and freedom. It’s still work in progress.
If you take a deeper look, you will know that just about everything is fine to talk about (today or even after the proposed law), the issues that would land someone in Jail like it did for Toujan Faisal, Laith Shubailat and many other outspoken “opposition” are, and will continue to land people in Jail. Extending a law to include cybermedia isn’t something new, nor is it something that will EVER, no matter how hard people worked, would EVER be accepted in Jordan. EVEN if and this is a MAJOR IF there was a constitutional amendment to protect these liberties.
March 12, 2010 at 10:59 pm
Dee
No i know very well i have never lived in this oasis you mention hehe..just like shadi said we never really had 100% freedom to say whatever we want in the first place, but the law is still not clear to this moment, and if it goes as far as everyone has suggested a while back in censoring everything out there then there’s definitely going to be a problem, there are a lot of people blogging anonymously and that would certainly change, there are hundreds of groups and pages on facebook that i’m sure will be included and counted as offensive when the censoring begins, there are loads of news websites that are already censoring their own comments and would basically not be able to view not one comment if this would come to be, i’m even afraid this post and the many others talking about censorship itself would always be something to be afraid of. Wr still don’t know what will happen, and to tell you the truth even the ones who landed in jail in my opinion shouldn’t. To each his own i guess.
March 13, 2010 at 12:44 am
Yazan
Quite a harsh post to be honest, but I really agree with every word you said. Although freedom of speech rights in Jordan are way better than other Arab and Middle Eastern countries, there remain to be quite a few boundaries to the subjects that we can debate about. ..and YES, fear is a major factor contributing to the reluctance of a person to speak their mind on the web in my opinion. Thank you for the enjoyable read.
March 15, 2010 at 1:48 am
Dee
well i think if we’re not harsh enough and show our position on the issue then we will just give them a chance to take us to that level of other arab countries where multiple websites are blocked and you can’t open your mouth about anything..
March 13, 2010 at 2:34 am
hamdanism
I like the picture lool
March 15, 2010 at 1:46 am
Dee
okayyyy abed..amazing comment :p
March 18, 2010 at 7:34 pm
Dino
in the arab world even when they say “say what you want” or “freedom of speech” it means . you better say what your supposed to say or get in big trouble. its like… and ppl have this fear of saying what is on thier mind. fear of speaking the truth. we live in a world full of lies and hypocrisy and wasta. and well.. its been that way min alf saneh nothin new in tha department
March 19, 2010 at 5:28 pm
Dee
yes true…we just hope that if we ever do get the ‘really say what you want and we won’t do a thing’ then one generation will come which will be born into that and know only that..the change will start then i guess…
thank you for your comment
March 12, 2011 at 9:32 am
Haitham Al-Sheeshany
Very good read as always, I have nothing else to add! L kol sabagoony, loool
March 12, 2011 at 10:25 am
Dee
haitham this is last years #B4JO.. this years will come tonight
March 12, 2011 at 11:55 am
Haitham Al-Sheeshany
malkom enti o shadz ,, loooooooooool
I KNOWWWWWWWWWWWWW
good read el muhim + awaiting